This post may contain affiliate links. Please refer to our disclosure policy.

If you’re anything like me, you’ve probably stared at your homeschool schedule at the end of a chaotic day, wondering where the time went. Do your homeschool days run smoothly? Does everything you want to accomplish have a satisfying check mark next to it? I know mine didn’t -not at first, anyway. With three kids all 5 and under, my early homeschooling attempts were a whirlwind of frustration.

The subjects we completed regularly didn’t always align with our priorities, our curriculum’s schedule would be thrown off track, consistency felt like a distant dream, and feeling satisfied with our efforts? That was completely foreign to me. I was constantly playing catch-up, feeling guilty about what we didn’t get to, and stressed about whether my little ones were truly learning what mattered most. Sound familiar? If you’re nodding along, you’re not alone.

Homeschooling, especially with young children, is a beautiful adventure, but it comes with its fair share of bumps. The good news? I finally refocused on our family’s priorities and tried a new way of doing things: the Subject Priority Approach. This simple yet powerful strategy transformed our homeschool schedule from overwhelming to manageable -and even enjoyable!

We’ll dive deep into why the Subject Priority Approach might be the perfect fit for your homeschool schedule, how to determine your family’s unique priorities, and practical steps to implement it. Whether you’re juggling toddlers, dealing with unpredictable life events, or just trying to fit in all the “extras,” this approach keeps the focus on what truly counts. By the end, you’ll have a customizable homeschool schedule that brings peace, progress, and that satisfying end-of-day checkmark. Let’s get started!

(Quick note: The Subject Priority Approach is excellent if you’re an eclectic homeschooling parent, pulling from various methods and resources. To read more about types of homeschool methods, check out our Homeschool Methods post).

Read Next: Curated Versus All In One Homeschool Curriculum

Why the Subject Priority Approach Might Be the Best Fit for Your Homeschool Schedule

Homeschooling isn’t one-size-fits-all, and neither should your homeschool schedule be. The Subject Priority Approach shines in families where flexibility is key. It ranks subjects by importance (we’ll call them Priority A and B), ensuring that even on “off” days, your child is progressing in the areas that align with your family’s goals. No more guilt over skipped science experiments when math and reading are solidly checked off!

Let’s break down three common scenarios where this approach can revolutionize your homeschool schedule. If any of these resonate, keep reading—you might just find your new go-to strategy.

1. The Season of Life You’re In Is Unpredictable

Homeschooling is unpredictable -period. Someone wakes up sick, there’s an unexpected injury, regular checkups pop up, lessons need rescheduling, a new baby arrives, vacations interrupt the flow, or family visits turn your routine upside down. And that’s just the tip of the iceberg!

Some homeschooling lifestyles lean toward a more consistent homeschool schedule, like families with older, independent learners or minimal external commitments. But others face additional stressors that make days inconsistent. Think: welcoming a new addition to the family, managing a homestead with daily chores, being a military family with frequent moves, relocating for a parent’s job, handling a child’s packed extracurricular calendar (sports, music lessons, co-ops), or balancing a parent’s business obligations. I’ve been there -our homestead throws curveballs, babies are born, children have to go to the doctors, and so the list goes on.

Ultimately, seasons of life change rapidly, especially with little ones. One month you’re in a groove; the next, teething or a growth spurt derails your nights and naps are back on the schedule. Basing your homeschool schedule on subject priority helps you navigate these unpredictable times while still feeling reassured that your child is learning what’s important. Instead of forcing a rigid timetable that crumbles at the first hiccup, you prioritize “must-dos” and let the rest flex. This builds resilience in your schedule and reduces burnout. Practical tip: Start small. Identify just 3-5 core subjects as non-negotiable, and watch how even partial days feel productive.

2. You’re an Overambitious Planner When It Comes to Your Homeschool Schedule

Raise your hand if you’re guilty of this: Your planning-self is overoptimistic! In my head, I envision an ideal homeschool schedule where we cover all the things—reading, math, science, history, art, foreign language, music, nature walks, and more. If I just plan our homeschool schedule perfectly, we’ll squeeze it in, right? Wrong. Cue reality: Sickness sweeps through the house for two weeks straight, impromptu emergency room visit for stitches, rescheduled piano lessons due to a teacher’s conflict, unexpected hens added to the flock, or out-of-town family dropping by unannounced. The list goes on and on. It’s not a question of if something will throw our homeschool schedule off—it’s a matter of when.

I used to beat myself up over these interruptions, staring at my color-coded planner with unchecked boxes. But the Subject Priority Approach changed that. Your planning self can be overambitious -dream big! The difference? At the end of the day, even if you didn’t get to all the things, you still have that feeling of reassurance because your child learned what’s most important.

How does it work in practice? Let’s say your ambitious plan includes 10 subjects. With priorities, you focus on 4-5 “A” subjects daily (we’ll get into how to choose these!). The rest? They become “B” subjects for when time allows. This prevents overload and turns potential failures into wins. Friendly advice: Use a simple planner (digital or paper) to list priorities visibly. Seeing “Reading: Done!” amid chaos is a mood-booster. Over time, you’ll be able to plan more realistically, but without stifling your enthusiasm.

3. You Find It Difficult to Fit Everything Into Your Homeschool Schedule

Your homeschool schedule is filled to the brim most days, especially when homeschooling little kiddos -age matters a lot here. Young children rely heavily on parents as the primary teacher, needing guidance through every subject, every minute. A kindergartener might need you to read aloud, demonstrate math manipulatives, or hold their hand through handwriting practice. It’s hands-on, all day!

As your child grows and their reading level rises, they gain independence. A 10-year-old might read a history chapter solo or complete math worksheets with minimal help. But in the early years? Not so much.

The number of kiddos factors in too. With one child, you might juggle subjects seamlessly. Add siblings? Each needs help with lessons or just attention from Mom (or Dad). Throw in household duties -like laundry, meals, or cleaning -maybe homestead chores (feeding animals, gardening), and carving out personal time for self-care? Whew! In a single day, our time simply cannot be dedicated to teaching all subjects to every child.

The Subject Priority Approach helps you analyze the most important subjects to fit into your homeschool schedule. Which ones will set your child up for independent learning in a few years, reducing demand on you? For us, prioritizing reading early meant my oldest could soon devour books alone, freeing me for the younger ones. Practical step: Audit your day. Time how long each subject takes, then rank by future payoff. This trims the fat without cutting depth.

Determine Priorities Based on Your Family’s Goals

Now that we’ve explored why your homeschool schedule might benefit from the Subject Priority Approach, let’s get practical: determining your family’s priorities. I can’t give a one-size-fits-all formula for that end-of-day reassurance -every family is unique, with different aspirations, desires, and values. What works for a literature-loving family might not for one focused on STEM or faith.

But I can share questions to spark your thinking. Answer them honestly, in an “ideal world” mindset. I’ve turned these into a free printable—grab it below! Also, check out The Ultimate List of Homeschool Subjects to see the whole picture.

Pro tip: Have your spouse fill it out separately, then compare notes. Discussions like this strengthen your homeschool vision.

Here are the questions:

1. If someone were to ask you to describe your ideal homeschool environment in 3 words, what would those be? (E.g., peaceful, rigorous, joyful.)
2. When your child looks back on their homeschool time, what are the three words you hope they would use to describe it? (E.g., adventurous, foundational, loving.)
3. When your child leaves the house to begin their own life, what are the top 3 things you want them to hold above all else? (E.g., faith, critical thinking, kindness.)
4. At your child’s current age, which four subjects stand out as the best to set your child up for success in learning in a year or two? (E.g., reading, math, handwriting, phonics.)
5. At your child’s current age, putting aside foundations for immediate future learning, what would you like them to be well-rounded on? Write down as many that come to mind. (E.g., history, art, science, music, foreign language.)
6. What subjects are difficult to pick up after an extended break? (E.g., math facts, piano practice, spelling rules.)
7. Ask your child what interests them.
8. If your homeschool schedule could only fit one subject, what would it be? Choose one from question 4.

How to Use These Questions for Your Homeschool Schedule

Let’s unpack this step-by-step—it’s like building a custom puzzle for your homeschool schedule.

• Questions 1 and 2: These gauge your overall vibe and help determine quantity. Words like “peaceful” and “relaxed” suggest fewer subjects (maybe 3-4 total priorities). “Rigorous” and “well-rounded”? Go for more (up to 6 or 7, if kids are older/independent). This prevents overload from the start.
• Questions 3, 4, and 6: These pinpoint Priority A subjects -the non-negotiables for daily/near-daily completion. Question 3 ties to life values (e.g., faith might make Bible study A). Question 4 focuses on building blocks for independence. Question 6 highlights momentum-killers (skip math for a week? Regression city!).
• Questions 5 and 7: These feed Priority B -the enrichers. Question 5 is for well-roundedness; Question 7 makes it child-led, boosting engagement. (If interests are huge for you, bump a B to A.). The best part for Priority B subjects is that these can usually be honed in on when your child is older and more independent because of the foundation you gave them.
• Question 8: The ultimate tiebreaker! This is your “gold medal” subject -the one that must happen, even on bare-bones days. For us, it’s reading/phonics for my younger kiddos and math for my eldest.

Take time here. Brew coffee, pray or journal, involve the family. Our answers evolved: Early on, survival mode meant basics only. Now, with a second grader, we layer more.

Establish Priority A Subjects for an Optimal Homeschool Schedule

Priority A Subjects are your heavy hitters -completed 4-5 times per week (adjust based on preference/curriculum). These are most important for your child’s education and that accomplished feeling for you at the end of the day. Limit to 5 academic subjects max for young kids -more sets you up for failure unless teens handle independent work.

Dividing Priority A Subjects to Fit Into Your Homeschool Schedule

Structure around your rhythm. We kick off with a morning basket almost daily -a cozy group time with read-alouds, songs, and memory work. My Question 3 answer (sound moral character, wisdom, loving Jesus) fits perfectly: Aesop’s Fables, The Book of Virtues, Bible stories, hymns, verses. We reinforce with church twice weekly and family-focused homeschooling.

For academics (current ages: 7, 5, and 4):

• 7-year-old: Math, piano, handwriting, spelling, and grammar.
• 5-year-old: Reading, piano, math, and handwriting.
• 4-year-old: Alphabet and math.

Time-wise, my eldest can finish his Priority A Subjects in less than 2 hours. My middle kiddo finishes his in 1 hour and my youngest takes make 20 minutes. These numbers aren’t perfect though because we’re not in a vacuum. There’s friction daily whether that’s from emotions, feelings, sibling distractions, or who knows what else. It’s rare that we have our undivided attention all on the work and it is completed in that timeframe.

Why You Might Choose the Same A Subjects

The Written Word: Reading, Writing, and Spelling

Question 8 gold: Reading. It’s our #1 because once a child reads fluently and loves it, the world opens. No waiting for Mom to explain dinosaurs -they grab a book! We foster love via cozy read-alouds, a children’s library, and audiobooks in the car. Classics like The Railway Children, The Secret Garden, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, and The Hobbit all build vocabulary and imagination.

Read Next: 36+ Classic Kid Read Aloud Books

Writing follows: Strengthens fine motor skills (hello, art prep!) and idea communication. Handwriting practice doubles as character-building (patience!). Spelling tags along -embedded in reading but consistent for mastery.

Subjects That Support and Enrich: Math and Piano

Math: Daily life essential that requires consistency to continue progressing. This subject also builds logic and early gaps hurt later. We use hands-on tools (blocks, games) for fun in the early grades and buckle down into workbooks as they advance.

Piano: Daily practice retains skills and allows for future progress. Also, learning to read music is like learning a second language and starting young wires the brain like nothing else can. Bonus: Recitals build confidence, church playing serves others.

These A subjects compound -reading unlocks self-learning, math/piano add discipline.

Establish Priority B Subjects for the Optimal Homeschool Schedule

B Subjects: 4 or fewer, age-dependent. You can opt for formal teaching and a curriculum, just be sure to pick a flexible curriculum that allows the more relaxed approach to translate to the subject’s study. In an ideal day we work 2 B subjects into our afternoon and rotate the subjects so all 4 are seen 2-3x each. But if they’re each only seen once, or not at all, I’m okay with it.

The reason it doesn’t bother me anymore is because our most essential, foundational subjects are being taught and learned consistently. The A subjects will allow my kiddos to learn these B Subjects in the future, or keep the kiddos progressing in a foundational subject.

Why You Might Choose the Same B Subjects

Top B Subjects: Branch Off A and Student-Led (History and Art)

History: Ties to morals/wisdom. Past lessons via stories, timelines. My eldest devours it.

Art: Techniques, artists, creating. We have How-To Draw books available for the kids anytime which allows them to lead for the creating aspect of art. We also have a series of books that focuses on famous artists and are written for kids. All these readily available resources allows the door to be opened at anytime but will also be available later when they’re more independent in their learning.

Naturally Taught in Lifestyle: Spanish and Science

Spanish: Young brains absorb languages. Books, songs, flashcards, and movies introduce sounds but for actual learning of the language, that can come later if there isn’t time for foreign language quite yet.

Science: Rural life/homestead integration -outdoor play, animal care, gardening, and weekly nature group are all natural learning experiences. A formal textbook curriculum is great when the time allows.

Drop subjects seasonally if needed and revisit when the kiddos are more independent.

Things to Consider When Structuring Your Homeschool Schedule Using Subject Priority

• Reevaluate Goals Yearly: New ages, skills, interests. Tweak the subjects and their ranking of priority accordingly.
• Daily/Weekly Schedule Tweak: This is a fluid/flexible consideration in our home but I have found it is beneficial to take a step back and look at the bigger picture every few months. It allows me to see where we might be getting bogged down and consider different approaches.
• Organize by Lifestyle: Morning basket for group subjects (such as history, memory work, faith). Individual subjects (math, spelling, reading) may be best for individualized time or working in tandem at the same subject but at different levels.
• Make-Up Strategies: Weekend days are for missed A subjects and we can always double up on short lessons if we’re feeling behind.
• Flexibility First: Has some time went by since B subjects have even had any thought? Don’t feel guilty for the neglect (there’s a reason they’re B subjects) but you can swap in! Or maybe it’s time to reevaluate your daily/weekly homeschool schedule. Has whatever derailed them in the first place moved on and we just haven’t thought to incorporate them again? I’ve been guilty of this, think first trimester nausea and fatigue.
• Tracking: The best way to track this Subject Priority is with the Reverse Planning Method. Discover why I love this flexible planning so much and grab a free printable to get you started!

Subject Priority Allows Your Homeschool Schedule to Be Flexible

Some days are bound to flop, that’s the nature of doing school at home. Maybe only 2 A subjects, or none at all are completed. Make it up on the weekend or make time for an extra lesson during the week. Remember that consistent priorities = progress reassurance.

Are you struggling just to check off daily A subjects consistently? You might be over-optimistic! Drop an A subject or 2 down to B (what is least foundational and doesn’t require consistency). For example: I was over-optimistic when my eldest was 6. I had Spanish and Spelling in our Priority A list. We just couldn’t get to them with everything else daily. Instead of continuing to feel guilty or like we hadn’t accomplished anything (these were 2 out of 6 subjects -so 4 were being completed daily) I decided to nix Spanish and move spelling to the Priority B list.

Troubleshooting Common Roadblocks in Your Priority-Based Homeschool Schedule

Let’s be real: even the most thoughtful homeschool schedule will hit potholes. The Subject Priority Approach isn’t a magic wand that erases tantrums, teething babies, or the day the washing machine floods. What it does do is give you a clear north star so you can steer around (or through) the mess without losing your mind -or your priorities. Below are the five roadblocks I hear about most often in our community, plus a mindset shift and an actionable tweak for each. Pick one, try it for a week, and watch the ripple effect.

1. The 10 a.m. Meltdown Monster

“We start strong, but by mid-morning my kid is melting down and nothing gets done.”

Mindset Shift: A meltdown isn’t a schedule failure; it’s a signal that a need (hunger, movement, connection, or sensory reset) is louder than the lesson.

Actionable Tweak: Build a “Reset Button” into your homeschool schedule at the 90-minute mark.

• 5-minute dance party (playlist ready on your phone) or go for a walk to breathe in the fresh air.
• Snack + water + cuddle on the couch
• Independent Playtime and resume with the next Priority A subject -there is no guilt over skipping the one that triggered the spiral -just remember to come back to it.

Pro tip: If mornings are consistently rough, try a new routine: the toughest A subject right after breakfast when everyone’s fresh, then hit morning basket. Does your child have a ton of ants in his pants in the morning? Prioritize play early for afternoon lessons.

Read Next: The Best Tips for Homeschooling Boys

2. Sibling Interruptions That Derail One-on-One Time

“I’m teaching the 6-year-old phonics and the 3-year-old is hanging off my leg or ‘helping’ by dumping pretzels all over the pantry.”

Mindset Shift: Interruptions aren’t sabotage; they’re training for real life. Your Priority A subjects still move forward even if the setting is messy.

Actionable Tweak: Create Busy Stations

• Give individual time to the younger sibling before beginning lessons with the older kiddo. This meets their need for attention so they’re more likely to play independently.
• Provide the younger sibling with a rare toy in a safe and contained space (high chair, play area). The key here is that they have a toy they don’t play with often and takes zero adult input (magnetic tiles, a lacing card).
• If needed a crib break for little ones can be beneficial for everyone. This simply means that the baby goes into their crib for the 10 minutes you need to finish a lesson.

Read Next: Homeschooling with a Baby and Toddler

3. Curriculum That Takes Longer Than the Box Says

“The math lesson claims ‘20 minutes’ but we’re still on problem 3 after 45.”

Mindset Shift: The curriculum serves your priorities, not the other way around. If a resource consistently overruns, it’s misaligned with your season, not your teaching.

Actionable Tweak: Set a time limit (that only you’re aware of) and be okay skipping problems.

• Open the lesson and silently highlight the core concept (usually 1–2 pages or 3–4 problems).
• Teach only that chunk; repetitive work and your child is doing great? Skip a chunk of problems -there’s no complete every problem in the workbook police that will show up at your door.
• If the child grasps it in 15 minutes, stop. If they need 30, stop anyway and finish tomorrow. Mark the page with a sticky note that says “Day 2.” Over a week you’ll still cover the material, but your homeschool schedule stays sane. Works for spelling lists or handwriting pages that spiral out of control.

4. Co-op / Errand Days That Nuke the Rhythm

“Wednesday is nature co-op from 10–1, and by the time we’re home we’ve lost the whole afternoon.”

Mindset Shift: Field trips and co-ops are school. Treat them as a block in the homeschool schedule, not an interruption.

Actionable Tweak: Adopt a “Co-op Eve & Co-op Lite” plan.

In all reality, if we’ve been out in the morning there’s an excellent chance we won’t do any lessons when we return home. But I am aware of this and plan accordingly. When we used to attend co-op I scheduled both co-op and piano lessons on the same day. My expectations for anything else were zero but by scheduling them on the same day I avoided derailing us twice in one week.

Currently, we have only piano lessons. Those are in the morning and we work through lessons while a sibling has their piano lesson. Whatever is not completed is saved for the following day. We still arrive home around noon but that afternoon is blocked off for appointments or cleaning the house. I have three boys and three dogs, I need more than half a day but this has been a game changer for the state of our home.

5. Parent Fatigue & the “I’ve Got Nothing Left” Slump

“By 2 p.m. I’m toast, but the checklist glares at me.”

Mindset Shift: Your energy is a finite resource, not a moral failing. Protecting it is part of the homeschool schedule. Rest can’t be optional, it’s what keeps priorities alive and protects your mental health.

Actionable Tweak: Institute “Mom’s 30-Minute Power-Down.”

1. Set a timer for 30 minutes to an hour after lunch (or whenever the slump hits).
2. Everyone chooses a quiet, independent activity: books, drawing, Legos, nap.
3. You sit with tea, a podcast, or even shut your eyes -no screens, no chores.
4. When the timer ends, tackle one remaining A subject together or a B subject if all A’s are completed.

Read Next: How to Protect Your Mental Health as a Homeschooling Mom

Final Encouragement

A consistent homeschool schedule isn’t about perfection -it’s about protecting your priorities. When a day implodes, look at what did happen: Did your gold-medal subject get touched? Great -that’s a win. Tomorrow is a fresh page. Keep tweaking, keep laughing, and remember: the goal is progress, not a Pinterest board. Share in the comments your own struggles and what you have done to overcome them?

Recent Posts on the Blog